I’ve been developing a overall branding concept, I’d like your thoughts on refining it and your reactions to it.
“All brands outlive their useful life, often to the detriment of the consumer and newer value propositions.”
David Dalka attends and reports business events and conferences to discover the future of business where technology, organizations and customer exeperience meet. Also serves as emcee, moderator and motivational business keynote speaker.
Branding/Buzz/Viral
I’ve been developing a overall branding concept, I’d like your thoughts on refining it and your reactions to it.
“All brands outlive their useful life, often to the detriment of the consumer and newer value propositions.”
Ideally a gift card giveaway should work like this: fill out form (either on paper or online), perform requested action and get a gift card in a timely manner without hassle. It would even be better if they gave cash. 🙂
This is how Mazda did it recently:
– Sent me an email in early March inviting me to test drive a Mazda and get a $25 gift card as I had previously signed up for promotions as some of the new models were of interest
– Printed off pdf file
– Filled out form
– Went to Mazda dealer
– Found salesperson who didn’t know about the promotion
– Had manager figure out the details
– Test drove a Mazda
– Mailed in form
– After 8 weeks card had not arrived and wrote blog post about it
– A week later, the card arrives in the mail and I pick it up as I leave the apartment
– Since it has no sticker on the card saying it’s not active, I proceed to try to use it at a gas station and the guy tells me it’s not activated
– Went to myecount.com and filled out a form that was just way too long (see below)
– Put in mazda as my password for secret questions – for $25 this just is not necessary
– Unchecked default boxes to get updates from myecount.com
– Finally spent card
– Wrote post on this non-optimal customer experience in terms of duplicate data entry, time, cost and user utility
This is a great example of how not to run a promotion, not exactly a good idea when you are trying to get someone to build trust in your brand for a 5 figure purchase.
See the full size of this form here.
Congrats to LeBron James and the rest of the Cleveland Cavaliers team for becoming the 2007 NBA Eastern Conference Champions!
Few things I’ve ever seen on an online newspaper site have shown such a true respect and understanding of the radical change in the newspaper medium as the homepage of Cleveland.com did today. More and more people read only online. There it was in the middle of the page it said “Download today’s front page”(of the paper edition). Wow! I downloaded the pdf and it looked sweet.
I bet that pdf file becomes the De facto cube poster in every office in Cleveland on Monday. Cool Cleveland.
That pdf file is interesting for other reasons as well. It’s also a great branding and advertising tool in stealth form. Take a closer look at the pdf file again. It brands the Plain Dealer in the top left corner. It is also a sales piece. Look at the bottom left corner now. It has URLs to purchase both pictures from the game and a larger poster of the front page.
Now if only (URL no longer active) cleveland.com would remove the age, zip code and sex question on the entry pages like Cleveland’s Joel Cheesman wants. 90210 anyone?
I got an email from Mazda in March to get a $25 VISA Gift Card for taking a test drive. I’m considering buying a new car in the not too distant future to replace my aging Acura Integra (I should be buying another Acura but they no longer make cars with appropriate headroom for a 6’3″ adult – but alas this is another post).
I completed the test drive, mailed in the form and 8 weeks later I still have not received this gift card. It appears I have plenty of company as well based on these message board posts. Not a good way to treat prospects of your 5 figure products. If you can’t send a gift card in a timely manner, does this experience build confidence that you will be dealt with fairly if something went wrong with your new Mazda? No.
When companies are creating incentives to interact with their products and services why aren’t they realizing that how the experience is handled can have considerable impact on their brand – either positive or negative?
You will recall that last year, Federated Department Stores, now Macy’s, changed the name of Marshall Field’s to Macy’s. Now that flagship State Street store is well on it’s way to failing. It wouldn’t surprise me if someone was trying to buy it from them right now to start it anew. When history examines this, it will see lessons of branding and hospitality.
According to the Chicago Tribune, a press conference after its (Macy’s) annual meeting here Friday, Federated’s chief financial officer, Karen Hoguet, said former Field’s stores are performing no worse or better than the roughly 400 regional department stores Federated acquired from St. Louis-based May Department Stores Co. in 2005 and converted to Macy’s. But there is an exception: the Chicago store on State Street. The landmark store, long a tourist destination, is “doing badly,” Hoguet said, without providing specific performance data.
After listening to Danny Meyer yesterday (see post below) I can’t help but noticing this wasn’t about a store, it was about hospitality, word of mouth and networking and the way people felt during that customer experience. A recent post on Marshall Field’s – fieldsfanschicago.org message board (which is amazingly still getting strong traffic – you may recall I stated I thought this issue had blogsphere legs back in September) says it best:
“I miss shopping in Marshall Field’s because Field’s IS Chicago. For me shopping at Field’s was an adventure because Field’s was more than a store…it was an institution which made people feel special just being there amongst the special merchandise that only Field’s could offer and the sales people made even the transactions memorable because of the way they wrapped items, hard and soft, in white tissue paper sealed with a green MF sticker before generously pulling out a large MF forest green shopping bag in which to place my purchases. That was ‘the frosting on the cake’.”
“But you know what I r-e-a-l-l-y notice at commuter train stations, on North Michigan Avenue, on State Street and in the Chicagoland shopping centers, at O’Hare and Midway and at other airports around the country???? I miss seeing people, by the dozens and dozens carrying the distinctive green Marshall Field’s sturdy shopping bags with the handles! The absence is so barrenly striking. You readily KNEW they were either FROM Chicago or had a fun shopping trip as a tourist and were going back home. You just do not find people carrying macy’s plastic sacks anywhere it seems, she added. Why should they?! Macy’s is everywhere, and therefore not special at all. It is all so sad.”
Do you hear this Mr. Lundgren?
Another reader posted in reply to the many clearance items at the store now…
“Customers want the stores converted back to Marshall Field’s not Marshalls.”
In a related matter, Macy’s has new problems due to accusations of a former LA Times reporter.
During my time in the New York City area, few things outside the financial services industry affected me more than the restaurants. Of those, few bring back fonder memories than my time in NYC than the Union Square Cafe and the restaurants that followed. These include the Grammercy Tavern, Eleven Madison Park, Blue Smoke & Jazz Standard, Shake Shack, The Modern and Hudson Yards Catering. The newsletter they send, a blog in paper form before there were blogs play a special role in building that bond.
What follows are the raw notes of Danny Meyer’s speech at the National Restaurant Association in Chicago on May 19, 2007. There are amazing insights in his speech and new book, Setting the Table, in regards to separating the concepts of service and hospitality, recruiting and how to life to it’s fullest. All lessons that can be applied to web 2.0 or any business in need of refined and high performance culture. Please note that the notes are raw and from his voice:
He let everyone know that it was his first time speaking at an NRA show. However, he attended the 1985 NRA convention. I wanted to learn about a POS system. We got a big presentation on it. I gathered the courage to ask a question. Is it really feasible to give a rolled thermal check instead of a proper check? If you give them good food at a fair price you can give them a check on toilet paper and they will come back someone chimed in.
Something dawned on me about five years ago. We focus on mistakes more than what is going right. My grandmother was proud of her garden. She taught me to garden at the age of 6. Ignore the weeds water the flowers. It dawned on me many years later that is what we should do in real life. A lot of things were going right.
Opening my restaurant was a passion. The strongest business decision I ever made was to fire myself as chef. In a city that has 22,000 restaurants, we have 6 in the top 42 Zagat Favorite Restaurants. People who are highly institutive make poor analysts. I do things that are intuitive. I employ over 1,500 now.
What does it mean to be my favorite (restaurant)? When you put those words in front of anything it is the highest compliment that can be paid. If I could figure out the secret sauce, Id have something. Location has ceased to be a critical fashion. The other 95% of the people say its’ service and not location, location, location. We needed a service economy. The car rental company didn’t have the convertible you wanted, the bank didn’t do what you wanted, etc. The Internet changed the rules. If you wanted to rise to the level of my favorite, you did if via performance. Performance used to be the thing that did it for you. I’ve always made a practice of asking why. You guys make the best roast chicken, you seat us on time, etc. We stopped hearing that when people started using the Internet. If you wanted to set yourself apart you could do things to differentiate, but replication happens much sooner now. Performance is a lot like air conditioning. Nobody has ever walked into the Grammercy Tavern and said this is great air conditioning, but if it doesn’t work, they don’t come back. Performance is now a lose proposition, it is not a win proposition. Nobody defined how hospitality is different than service. Did the waiter clear the table timely? Hospitality defines how you make someone feel. You have made them feel like you are on your side. Hospitality only occurs as we see it. Service is the technical delivery of product. You can write a manual to define the service and we have a different manual for hospitality. If you do something, do it consistently. Hospitality is not a monologue it’s a dialogue. The preposition for is involved in hospitality and the preposition to is there when you do something to somebody. It takes certain technical skills to open up a bottle of wine. We had been focusing 49% of skills training for technical skills. We spent the other 51% hiring for hospitality.
Hospitality IQ is the companies which are successful are the most successful in hiring the right hospitality. We need to hire people who derive pleasure from giving pleasure. What occurred to me is that you can’t teach it.
Kind, Intelligent and Curious, a high work ethic and integrity. These people were people with a high degree of empathy. Integrity is more than honesty. It is the judgment to do the right thing. More often than not they are life choices. Talked about leadership and the relationship to being a captain on a team. You get to be in a business of setting rules. Every single organization in the world have the exact same five stakeholders – customers, investors, community, employees and suppliers. We created a virtuous cycle of events. But if you believe in virtuous cycles, you can make more money by putting ourselves first, employees trust and put investors last. If I could raise my Hospitality IQ when hiring we’d be better. We put our community and suppliers ahead of investors to. Why would we have a community investment department? Why not help fix the park across the street. A rising tide lifts all boats. You might succeed at that. You can invest in the tide. Do your competitors go up with you? The niche of BBQ goes with the tide. Table is another example. We needed to create a new tide. We have been working to build community. In the same way that a championship horse is born with the DNA, it still needs to be trained. Make sure your staff needs to have the heart muscle worked hard. Birds of a feather flock together. The staff wants other people to work with that have a high hospitality quotient. People who have the same emotional need to learn pleasure. If you teach me more than the next guy, I’ll stay here. The biggest thing, please listen to my aspirations. We always want people to be part of a new opening of a new restaurant.
49% of a swans body mass is below water, 51% of the swan is above water doing the graceful stuff. My favorite chapter is the road to success is paved with mistakes well traveled. Waves are like mistakes, there is another one just behind it. My biggest mistake was back in 2002 and I found it hard to find the type of people. It took 35 minutes to get a drink on opening night at Blue Smoke. When I learned the swan theory, I never knew. Eye contact, a mile a hug and some pretty darn good food.
Question: Questions about putting staff ahead of customer.
What I’m saying is exactly that. If you have the best recipe, it’s not good if you don’t have good ingredients. Our hospitality will never rise to a higher level. The two things I look for in any business are focused on their work and enjoying each others company, I know it will work.
Question: When you were hiring for HQ, how do you train your managers.
Since you derive pleasure for making people for feeling comfortable, you can be blind to it. Have others help you. The prospect drops out that can be frustrating. I’ll ask someone, “Tell me how you used heart in your last job.” We tell people there are the skills that matter for you.
Question: Can you talk about the importance of the quarterly newsletter?
Listening is as important as expression. The fact that you think it’s quarterly when it’s twice a year is a testament to its’ effectiveness.
End.
It was a pleasure to listen to Danny speak. I’m glad I took the time to listen and learn from his wisdom about life and hospitality.
UPDATE: He had a book signing to go to at 2PM. At 4:45PM, I still saw him standing there with a line of people with books. Nothing short of amazing!
Apparently Google has considerable trouble in regards to the letter D.
First the Dmarc founders left Google.
Now http://www.dodgeball.com/ (dead link 11/2010) founders, Dens Crowley and Alex Rainert (please drop me a note if you read this guys), not only have left Google but they posed for a thumbs down photo that they have posted on Flickr, a Yahoo! property. The photo already has over 26,000 views and appears to have a viral element based on the view count growth, the interesting comments on the Flickr photo and a lot of blogosphere reaction. I’m trying to imagine how frustrated someone must be to post of photo of this nature, announce new project associations and state that they are throwing a party “to celebrate our escape”.
Putting my investment management hat on, I’d like for independent analysts to be allowed on the earning call this Thursday. If allowed to do so, I’d like to ask the following question, “Why is Google having such a hard time with HR and staffing issues, whether it is regarding hiring new employees, retaining pre-IPO employees (see podcast) or integrating acquisitions? Has Laszlo Bock’s background proven not to be the right style of leadership and is it time for a change?” The “all big companies are always ineffective” is a major cop out as there are big companies that are admired and in fact some cases adored.
Ideas on what to do with Dodgeball are everywhere you look. The comments on the Flickr photo are fascinating to read. P.S. When searching for these entries on Google Blog Search I found considerable splog/spam (MFA Made for Adsense) sites – Google should work to solve that issue.
http://spudswebnews.blogspot.com/2007/04/did-dodgeball-even-have-chance.html – Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post – Dead link November, 2013
http://www.blogator.com/g/2833510 (dead post 11/2010)
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
http://www.electrolicious.com/archives/2007/04/did_twitter_kill_it.html (dead post 11/2010)
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
http://www.yugatech.com/blog/gooooogle/google-bought-and-killed-dodgeball/ Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post – dead link 12 /2013
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
http://mcmanus.typepad.com/grind/2007/04/two_dodgeball_f.html (dead link 11/2010)
“http://topicstop.blogspot.com/2007/04/google-alert-google_1007.html (dead link 11/2010)
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
“http://ipfreaks.com/dreamscene/?p=2258” (dead post 11/2010)
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
“http://www.tmesolutions.co.uk/web_design_kent/Marketing+News/2007-04-16/Google+dumped+by+Dodgeball+founders/3800849030” (dead link 11/2010)
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
http://yummy.vermontconnect.com/cool/dodgeball-founders-leave-google-and-that-leaves-dodgeball-probably-dead/ (dead link 11/2010)
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
http://google.blogoscoped.cn/?p=417 Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post – Dead link November, 2013
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
http://www.spiceee.com/pensaletes/2007/04/16/dodgeball-founder-quits-google-will-google-kill-the-serviceDodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post – Dead post November, 2013
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
http://www.teknolife.com/tech-news/disgruntled-dodgeball-founders-leave-google-infoworld/ post removed
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
http://averageiq.org/dodgeball-founders-google.html – Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post – dead link November, 2013
http://averageiq.org/dodgeball-founders-google.html – Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post – dead link November, 2013
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
Dodgeball Founder Departure – April, 2007 post
EDIT: November 25th, 2012 – all of the URLs below are no longer active on the web, I’m removing them active link status:
http://youngmanhattanite.com/2007/04/ym-exclusive-dodgeball-founder-leaves.html
http://www.hypersuper.com/article/google-dodgeball-founder-quits-google-will-google-kill-the-service–610415
http://www.wayneporter.com/2007/04/16/dodgeball-knocked-out-by-twitter-google-snacks-on-dclk-is-twitter-next/
http://cellop.com/news/?p=2621
http://www.vecosys.com/2007/04/16/google-google-going-gone/
http://www.kpsforum.com/rss-news/10998-dodgeball-founders-leave-google.html
http://internet.webexpresspro.com/internet-news/disgruntled-dodgeball-founders-leave-google-infoworld
http://www.fixmood.com/dodgeball-founders-crowley-rainert-quit-google-in-frustration/2007/04/16/
http://techfold.com/2007/04/16/exodus-from-dodgeball-googles-growth-working-against-innovation/
http://www.infobong.com/wordpress/2007/04/16/linkdump-for-20070416/
http://pcniche.info/index.php/disgruntled-dodgeball-founders-leave-google/
http://indianinside.info/blog/2007/04/17/dodgeball-founders-quit-google/
http://socialnetworking.knowhow-now.com/blog/2007/04/16/disgruntled-dodgeball-founders-leave-google/
http://www.supermogul.com/2007/04/dodgeball_founders_dodge_veste.php
http://googlified.com/2007dodgeball-founders-leaving-google/
http://www.personalbee.com/227/12457964
http://dodgeball.sport-blog.biz/8626/dodgeball-founders-stop-playing/
http://mobiko.blogs.com/mutant/2007/04/dodgeball_found.html
http://coloradostartups.com/2007/04/16/overheard-at-the-googleplex/
http://ecpm.typepad.com/clickety_clack/2007/04/roundup_tellme_.html
http://www.vidfreeblog.com/2007/04/17/startup-meme-%C2%BB-dodgeball-founders-quit/
http://www.unofficialseoblog.com/2007/04/17/dodgeball-founders-quit-google/